Steak in Santa Cruz

Steak cuts and seafood pairings at The Water Street Grill in Santa Cruz, CA are available for pickup, including filet and rib eye.

Order online

Filet Mignon Steaks

Filet Mignon 8 oz

$42.90

Eight-ounce filet mignon with broccolini and a choice of potatoes.

“Filet Mingon was amazing; nice crust on the outside & cooked to perfection on the inside. Prawns had a little pop with each bite. Spinach ravioli was life changing with each swirl in the homemade pesto sauce. Mashed potatoes were smooth & broccolini tender crispy. Fun and/or romantic place to eat. Service was warm & welcoming. Will travel for this food!”

Filet Mignon 12 oz

$56.90

A 12-ounce filet is served with broccolini and a choice of potatoes.

“Wonderful environment and great music. Steak was amazing and the seasoning was crazy good! Pasta did not disappoint, definitely would recommend to any in the Santa Cruz area!”

Surf and Turf

Rib Eye With Lobster Tail

$69.90

12-ounce rib eye and paprika-pepper lobster tail with asparagus.

“The service was spectacular and the food was delicious. Steaks were cooked perfectly. What a gem!”

Filet Mignon With Lobster Tail

$79.90

Filet mignon and lobster tail come with asparagus and a potato choice.

“Simple and Nice cozy place to have a dinner with friends and family. They have a variety of options and the steaks were really good. Bang for buck in this area for sure.”

New York Strip Steak

A 12-ounce Certified Angus New York strip comes with asparagus.

“Excellent steaks!”

Ribeye Steak

Rib Eye

A 12-ounce rib eye comes with asparagus and your choice of potatoes.

“Start to finish amazing meal! Rib-eye steak was butter knife soft and seasoned perfectly! The vibe was romantic and relaxed. The mango lemonade was top notch 10/10 for refreshing! Amazing waitress!”

“Lovely little restaurant. Food was excellent. Had the calamari to start and then ribeye steak & prawns with mashed potatoes & asparagus...delicious! Portions were spot on & everything was seasoned well. Service was friendly & delightful. This is hidden gem in Santa Cruz.”

Prepared the The Water Street Grill Way

The Water Street Grill serves steak in New York, sirloin, rib eye and filet cuts. You'll find balsamic-marinated New York steak with slow-roasted garlic and sirloin with sweet grilled onions and mushrooms.

Rib Eye comes in a 12 oz portion with asparagus and potatoes. Skirt Steak pairs tender beef with broccoli and potatoes, while Filet Mignon 8 oz comes with broccolini and your choice of potatoes.

Visit us in Santa Cruz, CA for dine-in, pickup or delivery. New York With Shrimp pairs a 12 oz steak with lightly Cajun-seasoned shrimp, asparagus and your choice of oven-roasted red potatoes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular steak options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Rib Eye With Lobster Tail — A 12-ounce rib eye is served with an 8–10-ounce lobster tail, asparagus, drawn butter and a required potato choice.
Filet Mignon With Lobster Tail — An 8-ounce filet and 8–10-ounce lobster tail come with asparagus; choose potatoes, steak doneness, and a butter option.
Seasoned Sirloin Steak — Seasoned 10-ounce sirloin comes with sweet grilled onions, mushrooms and asparagus; choose potatoes, butter and steak doneness.
New York With Shrimp — A 12-ounce New York steak comes with lightly Cajun-seasoned shrimp, asparagus, potatoes, and a choice of steak doneness and butter.
Filet Mignon 8 oz — This eight-ounce filet mignon comes with broccolini and a required choice of mashed or oven-roasted red potatoes.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for steak throughout the Santa Cruz area. Order your steak online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

The Water Street Grill offers kid-friendly options, including Kids Grilled Cheese Sandwich and Kids Mac & Cheese.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.